Current:Home > InvestDemocrats are forcing a vote on women’s right to IVF in an election-year push on reproductive care-InfoLens
Democrats are forcing a vote on women’s right to IVF in an election-year push on reproductive care
View Date:2024-12-23 23:46:12
WASHINGTON (AP) — Senate Democrats are seeking to highlight Republicans’ resistance to legislation that would make it a right nationwide for women to access in vitro fertilization and other fertility treatments, holding a vote on the matter Thursday as part of Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer’s effort to drive an election-year contrast on reproductive care.
Sen. Tammy Duckworth, a military veteran who has used the fertility treatment to have her two children, has championed the bill, called the Right to IVF Act. The bill would also expand access through insurance as well as for military members and veterans.
“These are real solutions that would help tens of thousands of Americans every year build the families of their dreams,” Duckworth, D-Ill., said this week.
But most Republicans were expected to vote against advancing the measure, instead offering their own, alternative legislation that would discourage states from enacting outright bans on the treatment. Democrats in turn blocked it Wednesday.
The overtly political back-and-forth, with no attempt at finding a legislative compromise, showed how quickly Congress has shifted into a campaign mindset five months out from the fall election.
As Schumer seeks to protect a narrow Senate majority and buoy Democrats’ hopes of holding the White House, he has sought to spotlight Republican intransigence to federal legislation that would guarantee women’s rights to reproductive care. Democrats have campaigned heavily on the issue ever since the 2022 Supreme Court decision that ended a federal right to abortion.
Schumer, a New York Democrat, also held a vote last week on legislation to protect access to contraception, but Republicans blocked it, arguing it was nothing more than a political stunt. Republicans have also blocked previous attempts to quickly pass IVF protections. They stressed that they support IVF and said Schumer was once again playing to the campaign trail with Thursday’s vote.
“Despite some claims from my colleagues on the other side, protecting IVF is not a show vote at all. It’s a show-us-who-you-are vote,” Schumer said. “This will be a chance for senators on both sides to show their support for strengthening treatments for people who start families.”
Democrats say it is necessary for Congress to protect access to the fertility treatment after the Supreme Court in 2022 allowed states to ban abortions and the Alabama Supreme Court in February ruled that frozen embryos can be considered children under state law. Several clinics in the state suspended IVF treatments until the state enacted a law to provide legal protections for IVF clinics.
Senate Democrats said it showed how all types of reproductive care could be upended in many parts of the country after Roe v. Wade was overturned.
Most Republicans in Congress, meanwhile, have expressed support for IVF, but have also largely declined to tell states how to regulate reproductive care. Instead, two Republicans, Sens. Katie Britt of Alabama and Ted Cruz of Texas have sought to quickly pass a bill that would threaten to withhold Medicaid funding for states where IVF is banned. Democrats blocked that bill on Wednesday.
Cruz, who is running for reelection in Texas, said it showed Democrats were making a “cynical political decision.”
“They don’t want to provide reassurance and comfort to millions of parents in America because instead, they want to spend millions of dollars running campaign ads suggesting the big, bad Republicans want to take away IVF,” he said in a speech on the Senate floor.
Democrats argued that the GOP bill was insufficient because it would still allow states to enact laws that grant embryos or fetuses the same rights as a person. Abortion opponents in over a dozen states have advanced legislation based on the concept of fetal rights.
Sen. Patty Murray, the Washington Democrat who objected to quickly passing the GOP bill, dismissed it as “nothing but a PR stunt.”
But Republicans also criticized the Democratic bill. Britt said it “extends far past IVF. It also treads on religious freedom and protection.”
In the wake of the Alabama Supreme Court ruling, Christians, who have been a driving force in the anti-abortion movement based on the belief life begins at or around conception, have wrestled with the fertility treatment. The Southern Baptist Convention this week approved a nonbinding resolution that cautioned couples about using IVF.
With the Senate deadlocked on the issue, advocates for access to the treatment said families would be left in uncertainty.
Jamie Heard, who lives in Birmingham and had to suspend her effort to have a second child using IVF when the state Supreme Court made its decision, said the ruling left her both scared and angry. She has been able to continue the treatment, yet spoke alongside other IVF advocates at the Capitol Wednesday to urge lawmakers to act.
“There are still a lot of questions that we have about how to move forward,” Heard said.
veryGood! (333)
Related
- Powerball winning numbers for Nov. 9 drawing: Jackpot rises to $92 million
- London police say suspects in stabbing of Iran International journalist fled U.K. just hours after attack
- Messi, Inter Miami confront Monterrey after 2-1 loss and yellow card barrage, report says
- Disney prevails over Peltz, ending bitter board battle
- Stocks soared on news of Trump's election. Bonds sank. Here's why.
- Southern California hires Eric Musselman as men's basketball coach
- Is Caitlin Clark or Paige Bueckers college basketball's best player? What the stats say
- Caitlin Clark and Paige Bueckers have been in each other’s orbit for years. The Final Four beckons
- Skiing legend Lindsey Vonn ends retirement, plans to return to competition
- Treasurer for dozens of Ohio political campaigns accused of stealing nearly $1M from clients
Ranking
- Shawn Mendes Confesses He and Camila Cabello Are No Longer the Closest
- Swiss Airlines flight forced to return to airport after unruly passenger tried to enter cockpit, airline says
- NY state is demanding more information on Trump’s $175 million appeal bond in civil fraud case
- House explosion in New Hampshire leaves 1 dead and 1 injured
- Maine elections chief who drew Trump’s ire narrates House tabulations in livestream
- A Pennsylvania County Is Suing the Fossil Fuel Industry for Damages Linked to Climate Change
- Michael Douglas on Franklin, and his own inspiring third act
- Tuition increase approved for University of Wisconsin-Madison, other campuses
Recommendation
-
Amazon's 'Cross' almost gets James Patterson detective right: Review
-
Michael Douglas on Franklin, and his own inspiring third act
-
How Amanda Bynes Spent Her 38th Birthday—And What's Next
-
Trump says Israel has to get Gaza war over ‘fast,’ warns it is ‘losing the PR war’
-
Certifying this year’s presidential results begins quietly, in contrast to the 2020 election
-
Why Caitlin Clark and Iowa will beat Paige Bueckers and UConn in the Final Four
-
Jax Taylor and Brittany Cartwright Reveal Why They Put 2-Year-Old Son Cruz in Speech Therapy
-
'Great news': California snowpack above average for 2nd year in a row